oa De Jure - Case No 48856/2010 (GNP)
Surrogate motherhood agreements, condonation of non-compliance with confirmation requirements and the best interests of the child : recent case law



The confirmation of surrogate motherhood agreements has become a focus point of attention since the reporting of the judgment in (2011 6 SA 514 (GNP) (for which see, Carnelley " 2011 6 SA 514 (GNP)" 2012 179; Pillay & Zaal "Surrogate motherhood confirmation hearings: The advent of a fundamentally flawed process" 2013 475; Bonthuys & Broeders "Guidelines for the approval of surrogate motherhood agreements: " 2013 485; Louw "Surrogacy in South Africa: Should we reconsider the current approach? 2013 564; Nicholson C "Surrogate motherhood agreements and their confirmation: A new challenge for practitioners?" 2013 510). There seems to be general consensus that the judgment has not provided the anticipated, much needed guidance. The discrepancy between what the court preached and what it practiced (as succinctly phrased by Pillay & Zaal 2013 483) as far as the enforcement of the surrogacy provisions is concerned, forms a central theme throughout the published comments which, without exception, have been negative to varying degrees. The failure of the court to undertake a rigorous investigation into the court documents and the facts that underlie them, coupled with the inadequacy of the statutory provisions and the evident difficulty implementing them, have elicited a call for legislative amendment. However, none of the authors mentioned, anticipated the possibility of the factual scenario with which the court was faced in MS, the case under discussion. The lack of foresight is easy to explain. Since it was generally accepted that the Children's Act requires a surrogate motherhood agreement to be confirmed the artificial fertilisation of the surrogate mother, the possibility of the court considering a request for confirmation after the surrogate had been fertilised, was simply never entertained.


Article metrics loading...

This is a required field
Please enter a valid email address
Approval was a Success
Invalid data
An Error Occurred
Approval was partially successful, following selected items could not be processed due to error