oa Journal of Education - An analysis of needs talk in relation to sustainable development and education
|Article Title||An analysis of needs talk in relation to sustainable development and education|
|© Publisher:||Wayne Hugo|
|Journal||Journal of Education|
|Affiliations||1 Department of Curriculum Studies, Stellenbosch University|
|Publication Date||Jan 2007|
|Pages||83 - 95|
|Keyword(s)||needs discourses, sustainable development and United Nations Decade of Education|
The year 2005 marked the beginning of the United Nations Decade of Education for sustainable development. Commonly, sustainable development (SD) means development that does not compromise the needs of future generations. Therefore the term implies two broad categories of needs: needs of present generations and needs of future generations. In this paper, I theorise about these two categories of needs. More importantly, however, I theorise about needs discourses associated with sustainable development. In other words, I focus not only on needs as the distribution of satisfactions but also on the contested character of needs or the politics of needs. Nancy Fraser writes that ï¿½needs talkï¿½ functions as a medium for making and contesting of political claims: ï¿½it is an idiom in which political conflict is played out and through which inequalities are symbolically elaborated and challengedï¿½. Furthermore, she proposes a scheme for classifying the varieties of needs talk in late capitalist societies, suggesting that there are three major needs discourses: ï¿½oppositionalï¿½ discourses, ï¿½reprivatisationï¿½ discourses and ï¿½expertï¿½ needs discourses. All of these relate to sustainable development, but sustainable development produces another discourse which might be descriptionbed as a ï¿½futuresï¿½ needs discourse. In this paper I explore some of the current rival needs discourses and reflect on ï¿½futuresï¿½ needs discourses vis-ï¿½vis sustainable development. I also suggest some implications of my discussion for education.
Article metrics loading...