n South African Journal on Human Rights - Land rights that come with cut-off dates : a comparative reflection on restitution, aboriginal title, and historical injustice
|Article Title||Land rights that come with cut-off dates : a comparative reflection on restitution, aboriginal title, and historical injustice|
|© Publisher:||Juta Law Publishing|
|Journal||South African Journal on Human Rights|
|Affiliations||1 University of Ottawa, United States of America|
|Publication Date||Jan 2012|
|Pages||437 - 457|
ISI Social Science
The doctrine of aboriginal title allows for a distinct form of redress, empowering communities to use the judiciary to take action against the state for foundational acts of historical dispossession. It has not taken root in South Africa, yet in other former settler colonies of the British Empire, it remains important to this day. This article interrogates history and law to explain why this is the case. Such an approach allows for a critical reflection on the system of land restitution that developed in South Africa instead of aboriginal title. By exploring the past and present realities of 'dispossession' in South Africa, this article discredits the inclusion of cut-off dates in the Restitution of Land Rights Act. These dates have discriminated between claimant communities irrationally and insensitively - even racially. History should not be mobilised in statute law to obstruct the pathway to redress. It should, instead, be used positively to restore the rights of those formerly dispossessed, and to preserve the rights of those facing dispossessions pending, in South Africa.
Article metrics loading...