n South African Journal on Human Rights - The feasibility and desirability of an African disability rights treaty : further norm-elaboration or firmer norm-implementation?
|Article Title||The feasibility and desirability of an African disability rights treaty : further norm-elaboration or firmer norm-implementation?|
|© Publisher:||Juta Law Publishing|
|Journal||South African Journal on Human Rights|
|Affiliations||1 University of Pretoria and 2 University of Pretoria|
|Publication Date||Jan 2014|
|Pages||345 - 365|
|Keyword(s)||Disability, International law and Treaty making|
ISI Social Science
The United Nations General Assembly in 2006 adopted the Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities (CRPD), sparking debate in Africa about the desirability and feasibility of adopting an African pendant to this UN treaty. Two main rationales that support an 'African' treaty on the rights of persons with disabilities (PWDs) are examined in this article. The first is a process argument that contends that African participation in the elaboration of the CRPD was inadequate. The second, substantive argument suggests that the CRPD, itself, is defective, as it does not adequately address issues pertinent to and reflecting the life world of Africans with disabilities. Concluding that both rationales lack persuasive force, the authors identify two alternative courses of action. First, they argue that the CRPD should be prioritised and used to its fullest extent before attempts are made to elaborate parallel African standards to the CRPD. Among the measures to be prioritised are increased ratification, domestication, presentation of state and alternative civil society reports, and submission of individual complaints. Second, given that all African Union (AU) member states (except South Sudan) are party to the African Charter on Human and Peoples' Rights, they contend that the existing mechanisms under the African human rights system should first be fully exploited. Although the African human rights system may not have delivered sufficient results when it comes to PWDs, it has taken some tentative steps and has further unexplored potential. There is both a need and the potential for the regional system to play its part in advancing the rights of PWDs. In particular, the African Commission on Human and Peoples' Rights could draw inspiration from the recent adoption of its first General Comment (on art 14(1)(d) and (e) of the Women's Protocol) to spell out the implications of the African Charter for PWDs. Formulating a new treaty is a complex and time-consuming exercise that will further delay the effective implementation of states' obligations. However, if the option of an African-specific treaty gains wide support, it should take the form of a protocol to the African Charter, with the African Commission as monitoring mechanism, and not as a separate treaty with a self-standing treaty monitoring body.
Article metrics loading...