n Southern African Journal of HIV Medicine - Conserving (not preserving) culture : avoiding the damage to culture of veiled moralism in HIV education : opinion




Language mechanisms in much HIV discourse insist that a Western-based moralism dominates. These mechanisms include the use of strategic absences of information about the moral grounding of texts, and slippages of meaning where one word is used to refer to many meanings. A common slippage of meaning is use of the word 'polygamy' to refer to a range of behaviours, thus hiding low-HIV-risk sexual practices (polyfidelity) under the same umbrella as high-risk practices (promiscuity) and advocating their general removal. Another dubious method of achieving a moral position is to take a true premise and use it to advance a false conclusion. For example, the true premise that wife inheritance in its historical form is an HIV risk factor does not automatically lead to the conclusion that wife inheritance 'must' be eradicated. This is only one possible conclusion. Another more culturally sensitive conclusion could be that wife inheritance should be embarked upon, as should all sexual relationships, in a context of HIV tests and safer sexual practice. I argue that moralism (such as 'wife inheritance is morally wrong') cloaked as science (the claim that science 'proves' the moral position that wife inheritance is wrong) is a threat to traditional culture and discriminates against upholders of traditional lifestyles.

Drawing primarily from my experience of HIV education in a development setting in southern Africa, I offer a weak (realist) moral relativism as an alternative to on the one hand the positivist-based, absolutist morality that threatens to destroy traditional cultures in the name of HIV education, and on the other hand extreme cultural relativism in which 'anything goes'. Possibly HIV educators have not done enough to include some traditional safer sex practices in their professional inventory of acceptable behaviours, such as (thigh sex) and polygamy interpreted as polyfidelity. My hope is that by being more respectful of traditional culture, while encouraging cultural change where necessary, HIV education will register greater success in achieving safer sexual practice. This article will be particularly useful for writers and researchers tasked with achieving behavioural change and / or writing educational materials on HIV in the southern African context.


Article metrics loading...

This is a required field
Please enter a valid email address
Approval was a Success
Invalid data
An Error Occurred
Approval was partially successful, following selected items could not be processed due to error